PNOZ X3 or PNOZ s3? Five Questions That Settle Your Pilz Safety Relay Choice
Every machine safety circuit sooner or later runs into the same shelf decision: a PNOZ from Pilz, in either the classic X series or the compact s series. The two families protect the same hazards - emergency stop, safety gates, light barriers - but they differ in size, wiring style and expansion logic. Five questions, answered plainly, usually settle which one lands on the DIN rail.
Q: What does a PNOZ safety relay actually do that a normal relay does not?
It wires two redundant relay channels with positively driven (forced-guided) contacts and continuously tests both channels. If a contact welds shut or a wire shorts, the PNOZ detects it and refuses to close its safety outputs. Ordinary relays have no way to notice their own faults, which is exactly why a plain relay can never satisfy EN ISO 13849-1 for stop functions up to PL e.
Q: Where does the X series end and the s series begin?
The X series is the standalone classic: 45 mm wide, screw terminals built in, no configuration software, wire it and it runs. The s series shrinks the same safety logic into a 22.5 mm sigma-format housing with spring terminals, so a bank of PNOZ s modules fits where one PNOZ X3 would. Roughly:
| PNOZ X3 (e.g. 774310 / 774319) | PNOZ s3 (750103) | |
|---|---|---|
| Width | 45 mm, screw terminals | 22.5 mm, spring terminals |
| Safe outputs | 3 N/O + 1 N/C aux, 8 A (AC1/DC1) | 2 N/O, 6 A, plus 1 N/C aux |
| Inputs | 1/2-channel, with or without short detection | 2-channel with cross-fault detection |
| Reset / EDM | Automatic or monitored manual start | DIP-switch selectable, incl. EDM |
| Rating | PL e, Cat. 4 (EN ISO 13849-1) | PL e / SIL CL 3, response ≤ 30 ms |
Q: Which supply voltage version should I order?
Match the cabinet, not the datasheet habit. The X3 comes as 774319 (240 V AC / 24 V DC dual rating), 774310 (24 V AC/DC universal) and 230 V-only variants. In the s series, 750103 is 24 V DC, while 750110 and 750111 cover 115 V and 230 V AC/DC plants. Ordering the wrong voltage is the single most common PNOZ return, so check the control transformer first.
Q: How many safe outputs are enough?
Count every contactor coil and safety-rated load that must drop when the guard opens, then add one contact for the feedback loop. The X3's three 8 A N/O contacts typically drive a main contactor plus two auxiliary loads on their own; the s3's two 6 A contacts cover smaller circuits, and Pilz's expansion modules bolt on in the s format when a machine grows. If downstream contactors are large, remember the auxiliary contacts can switch them while the safe contacts carry the feedback.
Q: Automatic or manual reset - and what is EDM?
Automatic start (reset) brings the machine back the instant the E-stop is released; monitored manual start requires an operator to press a reset button, and most machine standards expect exactly that whenever a restart could surprise someone. EDM - external device monitoring - wires the contactors' auxiliary contacts back into the PNOZ so a welded contactor is caught before the next start. On the s3 both behaviours are DIP-switch selectable, on the X3 they are wiring choices, and either way the feedback loop costs two wires and prevents the classic failure of a safety circuit that looks green while the contactor below it is welded shut.



